Skip to Content

Do you really need an antibiotic?

It's normal to want relief from a fever, sore throat, and congestion — but antibiotics usually aren't the answer. Learn why.

September 21, 2022

If you’ve got a fever and you’re coughing, congested, or battling a sore throat, chances are you’re also missing work, losing sleep — and running out of patience. It’s natural to want to feel better as quickly as possible. Many people with flu-like symptoms think antibiotics are a quick-fix for their misery. But in most cases, antibiotics are not the answer.

Antibiotics are powerful drugs, but they aren’t a cure-all. They specifically target bacteria, killing these microscopic organisms or preventing them from reproducing. But most chest colds and other illnesses are not caused by bacteria.

“The vast majority of respiratory illnesses are viral,” explains David Johnson, MD, a primary care physician at Providence Family Medicine near Logan, Utah, affiliated with Cache Valley Hospital. “Antibiotics will not do anything to a virus. They will not help at all, and may cause significant harm.”

We're here for you. Cache Valley Hospital

Bacteria vs. virus: What’s the difference?

Bacteria are ubiquitous. These one-celled microscopic organisms can be found just about everywhere in the environment — even in the human body. Different types of bacteria live on your skin, inside your mouth, and along your digestive tract.

Many of these microbes actually help you stay healthy. Only certain species of bacteria, including some that are normally found on the body, have the potential to make people sick, including Streptococcus, Staphylococcus, and E. coli. These and other types of bacteria are responsible for some common illnesses, like strep throat, bacterial pneumonia, and urinary tract infections (UTIs). The immune system can usually fight harmful bacteria on its own. More serious infections, however, are treated with antibiotics.

Antibiotics often work quickly. Even though these drugs may need to be taken for a week or more, people usually start feeling better and are no longer considered to be contagious after about 24 hours. Although antibiotics are highly effective against bacteria, they are useless against viruses — the culprits responsible for the common cold, the flu, and other viral illnesses that cause similar symptoms.

Unlike bacteria, viruses need a living host to replicate. These tiny germs consist of genetic material wrapped in protein.  Antibiotics won’t clear a viral infection, help you feel better, or prevent you from spreading the illness to others. 

The risks of antibiotic misuse

Since the symptoms of flu-like viruses are similar to the warning signs of a bacterial infection, it’s often tough to tell the difference. Feeling uncertain or frustrated, some people urge their doctor to prescribe them an antibiotic without knowing whether or not they really need it.

Every year in the United States, about 30 percent of antibiotics — some 47 million prescriptions — are still prescribed unnecessarily. This is not only unwarranted but also risky for two reasons:

  1. The number of drug-resistant germs is increasing as the arsenal of effective antibiotics is dwindling. Every time antibiotics are used, however, bacteria have a chance to adapt and become resistant to them. Overusing allows more bacteria to develop resistance, making them stronger and more difficult to kill.

    “The more you use an antibiotic, the less effective it may become in the future,” Dr. Johnson explains. “That certainly holds true for individuals, but also for the community.” 

    With few new antibiotics under development, scientists are concerned that the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria will undo progress that has been made against bacterial infections over the past 70 years. Eventually, the increased risk for tough-to-treat infections may complicate common injuries and routine surgeries, like joint replacements.

    Each year in the United States, some two million people develop infections that are caused by drug-resistant bacteria. These so-called “superbugs” claim at least 23,000 lives, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports.
  2. Like all medications, antibiotics may cause allergic reactions or other unwanted side effects. Taking these dugs unnecessarily exposes you to these risks without offering a potential benefit. Side effects from antibiotics may include:
    • Rash
    • Dizziness
    • Nausea
    • Diarrhea
    • Secondary yeast or bacterial infections
    • Irregular heartbeat
    • Tendonitis, or increased risk for tendon injuries

Things you can do

If you’re suffering from a range of symptoms, including a runny nose, cough, low-grade fever, sore throat, and other flu-like symptoms, you may have a virus. If so, antibiotics won’t help but there are some things you can do to ease your discomfort, including:

  • Rest
  • Drink plenty of fluids
  • Gargle with saltwater for temporary relief of a sore throat
  • Ask your doctor about over-the-counter pain and fever reducers, such as acetaminophen or ibuprofen
  • Use a cool mist vaporizer or humidifier to reduce congestion

You can also try over-the-counter cough remedies or saline nasal sprays to get temporary symptom relief. These should be taken only as directed. Some of these products contain more than one active ingredient. Read all labels to ensure you’re not taking too much of any one medication.

Viruses usually clear up in a week or two. If your symptoms persist for more than 10 days without improvement, you could have a bacterial infection or another health issue that may need treatment and you should see your doctor.

Some other warning signs and symptoms that should be evaluated by a doctor:

  • You have a persistent high fever and chills
  • Your fever or other symptoms gradually worsen over time, or improve initially but then get worse
  • You feel short of breath
  • Your sore throat develops very suddenly, and you have tiny red spots on the roof of your mouth

Your doctor can perform a physical exam and tests to determine if you have a bacterial infection or another health issue that requires treatment. Sometimes a blood or urine test may also be needed to confirm or rule out a diagnosis. 

“I would say a temperature above 100.5 [Fahrenheit] for more than 48 hours that’s just not getting better should certainly prompt somebody to get checked out,” advises Dr. Johnson. “Let somebody look at you so that we can try and figure out if there's something else going on or something we need to treat.”

Seek immediate medical attention if you’re having trouble breathing, are in severe pain, or if you’re confused or disoriented. These may be symptoms of a life-threatening infection or other medical emergency.

Dr. David Johnson, MD.
Dr. David Johnson, MD.

Dr. David Johnson, MD, practices at Providence Family Medicine, an affiliate of Cache Valley Hospital.

Learn more about Dr. David Johnson, MD or book an appointment.

September 21, 2022
Cache Valley Hospital